Introduce a comprehensive guide for creating and maintaining ADRs within the ISA-Frontend project. This includes an overview, structure, naming conventions, and process guidelines to ensure consistent documentation of architectural decisions.
4.2 KiB
ADR NNNN:
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Status | Draft / Under Review / Approved / Superseded by ADR NNNN / Deprecated |
| Date | YYYY-MM-DD |
| Owners | <author(s)> |
| Participants | <key reviewers / stakeholders> |
| Related ADRs | NNNN (title), NNNN (title) |
| Tags | architecture, , |
Summary (Decision in One Sentence)
Concise statement of the architectural decision. Avoid rationale here—just the what.
Context & Problem Statement
Describe the background and the problem this decision addresses.
- Business drivers / user needs
- Technical constraints (performance, security, scalability, compliance, legacy, regulatory)
- Current pain points / gaps
- Measurable goals / success criteria (e.g. reduce build time by 30%)
Scope
What is in scope and explicitly out of scope for this decision.
Decision
State the decision clearly (active voice). Include high-level approach or pattern selection, not implementation detail.
Rationale
Why this option was selected:
- Alignment with strategic/technical direction
- Trade-offs considered
- Data, benchmarks, experiments, spikes
- Impact on developer experience / velocity
- Long-term maintainability & extensibility
Alternatives Considered
| Alternative | Summary | Pros | Cons | Reason Not Chosen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Option A | ||||
| Option B | ||||
| Option C |
Add deeper detail below if needed:
Option A –
Option B –
Option C –
Consequences
Positive
- …
Negative / Risks / Debt Introduced
- …
Neutral / Open Questions
- …
Implementation Plan
High-level rollout strategy. Break into phases if applicable.
- Phase 0 – Spike / Validation
- Phase 1 – Foundation / Infrastructure
- Phase 2 – Incremental Adoption / Migration
- Phase 3 – Hardening / Optimization
- Phase 4 – Decommission Legacy
Tasks / Workstreams
- Infra / tooling changes
- Library additions (Nx generators, new libs under
libs/<domain>) - Refactors / migrations
- Testing strategy updates (Jest → Vitest, Signals adoption, etc.)
- Documentation & onboarding materials
Acceptance Criteria
List objective criteria to mark implementation complete.
Rollback Plan
How to revert safely if outcomes are negative.
Architectural Impact
Nx / Monorepo Layout
Describe changes to library boundaries, tags, dependency graph, affected projects.
Module / Library Design
New or modified public APIs (src/index.ts changes, path aliases additions to tsconfig.base.json).
State Management
Implications for Signals, NgRx, resource factories, persistence patterns (withStorage).
Runtime & Performance
Bundle size, lazy loading, code splitting, caching, SSR/hydration considerations.
Security & Compliance
AuthZ/AuthN, token handling, data residency, PII, secure storage.
Observability & Logging
Logging contexts (@isa/core/logging), metrics, tracing hooks.
DX / Tooling
Generators, lint rules, schematic updates, local dev flow.
Detailed Design Elements
(Optional deeper technical articulation.)
- Sequence diagrams / component diagrams
- Data flow / async flow
- Error handling strategy
- Concurrency / cancellation (e.g.
rxMethod+switchMapusage) - Abstractions & extension points
Code Examples
Before
// Previous approach (simplified)
After
// New approach (simplified)
Migration Snippet
// Example incremental migration pattern
Open Questions / Follow-Ups
- Unresolved design clarifications
- Dependent ADRs required
- External approvals needed
Decision Review & Revalidation
When and how this ADR will be re-evaluated (date, trigger conditions, metrics thresholds).
Status Log
| Date | Change | Author |
|---|---|---|
| YYYY-MM-DD | Created (Draft) | |
| YYYY-MM-DD | Approved | |
| YYYY-MM-DD | Superseded by ADR NNNN |
References
- Links to spike notes, benchmark results
- External articles, standards, RFCs
- Related code PRs / commits
Document updates MUST reference this ADR number in commit messages:
ADR-NNNN:prefix. Keep this document updated through all lifecycle stages.